How people spend their free time and their own money is pretty much their own affair. Each one to their own taste. But it's always sad when you realise that someone is not doing what they think they are doing.
New Issue Collectors often seem to think that they are making an Investment for the Future, their own or their children's. Most of the time, they aren't. At the Paris Salon d'Automne, I used to watch from my Stand as - at the opening of the Show - hundreds of men (and a few women) ran towards the counters of La Poste to buy the latest "philatelic products" (as they are called in France). But every dealer watching knew that in a few years' time, those eager buyers would be lucky to get back 70% of the face value of the stamps they had purchased and which can only be sold off as "Postage" for use on the mail-outs from stamp dealers and auction houses. As an Investment, they do worse than keeping your money under the bed.
It's not a universal truth that buying New Issues is a doomed Investment. Agathon Faberge was a New Issues collector. He just had the good fortune to buy Zemstvos, often in sheets since the stamps only cost 1 or 2 kopecks each.
Heritage Collectors are not always philatelists and, as a result, often end up spending money on things which have nothing to do with the Heritage they think they are collecting. They are often enough victims of forgers and forgeries. It's quite often painful to look at "Heritage" collections for Armenia or Ukraine. You will see things which have never been near either country but have been fabricated in Paris or Moscow or California.
Some Heritage Collectors are more fortunate. If you go round a European stamp show looking for postal stationery cards written in Yiddish, you won't be disappointed - even now in 2014 nearly a hundred years after Yiddish started its post-World War One decline as a written language, you can find the cards in the boxes from Imperial Russia (the "Pale of Settlement" areas), from K u K Austria, and from Romania. It would be hard to fake them and not very rewarding - you will pay between 5 euro and 15 euro for a card, that's all.
Likewise collectors of their local Heimat - home town -do better than those who take a whole country as their heritage. Picture postcards and postmarks of your home town can be bought with reasonable confidence and often cheaply and it's generally easier to build up your own knowledge for a single town or city than for a whole country. Dresden is easier to master than Deutschland.
Of course, for a country like Armenia, Heimat collecting would be very frustrating. There just isn't the material, at any price. But for Ukraine, it's possible and, I think, fascinating. You don't even have to pick a big city.
The same is true for Russia and the Soviet Union and it surprises me that more collectors do not choose to concentrate on a single town or city. There are opportunities and surprises from Archangelsk to Zlatoust!
Ah, Vertical Collecting: just pick a geographical location (as small as a city or as big as a region) and collect anything from that area. Peter Ashford converted me to that style of collecting decades ago, but it's interesting that the field hasn't made more progress. Transcaucasia, Siberia, St.Petersburg and the Baltic area, that's it. I hear Mikhal Lapushkin is about to publish a postmark study of the Volga German area, to which I look forward eagerly, and I'm still chasing those Crimean postmarks myself, but apart from that... I think part of the problem is that material from anything other than the big cities just doesn't pop up that often. Kiev, Odessa, Warsaw - those you will be able to collect easily, but if you collect postmarks from, say, Kem or Kherson you're in for a long wait sometimes. My solution: collect lots of different things!ReplyDelete
Hope you don't mind some unabashed enthusiasm about your Russian and East European blog- it is clearly one of the best regional stamp blogs extant.
Although I collect classical WW, I find something of interest almost every time. The New Issue collecting and heritage collecting post is a case in point.
Consequently, I am adding a link for my Big Blue 1840-1940 blog.